Our global society is fast losing its balance and its moderate center. It is becoming more and more polarized and violent. Human life and dignity are losing their sacred character for an increasing number of people, including those who claim to be religious.
The atrocities perpetrated against civilians on September 11, 2001 and since, the war on terrorism, the horrific slaughter in Iraq, the interminable Arab-Israeli conflict including the latest Israel-Hizbullah war, the prospect of a nuclear-armed Iran, the sharp increase in oil prices, even cartoons deemed offensive to religious believers - all these factors have dashed any hopes that the end of the Cold War and the onset of a new millennium would generate a peace dividend, with greater international stability and prosperity.
Instead we witness more blatant expressions of authoritarianism, tribalism, religious extremism, terrorism, and militarism, together with a retreat from responsible politics and multilateral solutions. Ideology eclipses realism. Global organizations and initiatives remain hostage to narrow self-interest. The zero-sum game of power politics imposes its ugliness on our lives, mainly as a fearful, even desperate, reaction to terror.
As private and state terrorism continue to plague the world, it has evoked deep pain and revulsion in our psyches. The struggle against this vicious threat has generated a macro-myth that divides humanity into the "virtuous, righteous, heroic" fighters against the "evildoers." Such dehumanization simplifies complex problems and leads us away from effective strategies to counter the real threats we face. Whole populations are estranged from each other, waiting for the least provocation to denigrate and attack. Too often the threat is exaggerated, making the response incommensurate with the real danger.
We can easily succumb to despair when we feel helplessly vulnerable in the face of such horrors and threats. Primal survival instincts are apt to trump compassion, ethical restraints, and legal safeguards regarding human rights. Faith turns fanatic, and morality is sacrificed for short-term advantage. Power turns into brute force and evil deeds, and the weak discover their own strength in evil deeds, as well. Words become weapons, truth is warped into falsehood, and the human face dons the mask of death.
Why are we torturing and killing innocent civilians in the name of security or liberation? Why are warriors bombing residential neighborhoods and houses of worship and despoiling God's creation? Are cartoons mocking prophets and sacred traditions illustrations of free speech or of media insensitivity and irresponsibility? Is denying or belittling the Holocaust and other genocides a result of outright ignorance, or a sad commentary on our inability to face the truth, shoulder responsibility, and demonstrate solidarity with our fellow human beings? Isn't it sinful when civility, honor, and justice are crushed in the name of freedom or security? Isn't it a grotesque distortion of religion when tolerance, caring, and forgiveness are violated in the name of the Divine?
While the questions are legion, satisfactory answers elude us. What is clear is that we stand at a crucial juncture in human history, between a "clash of civilizations" and affirming the "dignity of difference."
Choosing the right path requires responsible leadership and a shared commitment to change negative attitudes and behaviors in favor of dialogue, conciliation, and a culture of peace. Such transformations must first happen within each one of us and in our interpersonal relationships. We must challenge ourselves, our compatriots, and our leaders-including religious leaders-to favor compassion over callousness, solidarity over selfishness, and peace with justice over the suppression of dissent.
The Western and Muslim worlds do not have to be like each other, or even like each other, to embrace dialogue and diplomacy as preferred methods of interaction. Muslims in Western countries can serve as cross-cultural mediators if they are enlisted and trusted by the disputing parties.
Enlightened self-interest and a concern for our children's welfare should suffice as motivations to work toward an accommodation of differences. Westerners and Muslims alike need rational, humane governance and better mutual understanding. Honest engagement with each other will reveal shared values, including a dedication to social justice. We all need political and economic reforms that distribute resources more equitably. We all need to safeguard human rights, increase funding for educational and cultural exchanges, and commit ourselves to resolving conflicts through peaceful means.
Winning the hearts and minds of others, particularly frightened or humiliated peoples, will not be achieved by hard power alone. Investing in peace-building and in basic human needs such as food, medical care, shelter, and education instead of high-tech weapons will create the necessary foundation for sustainable change in the direction of moderation, economic equity, and true peace. Our hope lies in first imagining, then working to create, an interdependent world in which the good of every individual depends on realizing the good of all.
Saliba Sarsar is Professor of Political Science and Associate Vice President for Academic Program Initiatives at Monmouth University New Jersey, USA. Yehezkel Landau is Faculty Associate in Interfaith Relations at Hartford Seminary in Connecticut, USA. They contributed this article to the Middle East Times.
Commentary: Reclaiming dignity and hope
TOOLBAR
To add a comment,
Please log in:
Don't have an account?
Register now to comment on stories and stay up to date on important events and issues in the Middle East with our newsletter.